Add implicit to path conversion to uploaded file (#28676)

* Add implicit to path conversion to uploaded file

Ruby has a few implicit conversion protocols (e.g. `to_hash`, `to_str`,
`to_path`, etc.). These are considered implicit conversion protocols
because in certain instances Ruby (MRI core objects) will check if an
argument responds to the appropriate protocol and automatically convert
it when it does; this is why you can provide a `Pathname` instance into
`File.read` without having to explicitly call `to_s`.

```ruby
a_file_path = 'some/path/file.ext'
File.write a_file_path, 'String Path Content'
File.read a_file_path

a_pathname = Pathname(a_file_path)
File.write core_file, 'Pathname Content'
File.read a_file_path

core_file = File.new(a_pathname)
File.write core_file, 'File Content'
File.read core_file

tmp_file = Tempfile.new('example')
File.write tmp_file, 'Tempfile Content'
File.read tmp_file
```

So how does an uploaded file work in such cases?

```ruby
tmp_file = Tempfile.new('example')
File.write tmp_file, 'Uploaded Content'
uploaded_file = ActionDispatch::Http::UploadedFile.new(tempfile: tmp_file)
File.read uploaded_file
```

It fails with a `TypeError`:

    no implicit conversion of ActionDispatch::Http::UploadedFile into String

In order to make an uploaded file work it must be explicitly converted
to a file path using `path`.

```ruby
File.read uploaded_file.path
```

This requires any code that expects path/file like objects to either
special case an uploaded file, re-implement the path conversion protocol
to use `path`, or forces the developer to explicitly cast uploaded files
to paths. This last option can sometimes be difficult to do when such
calls are deep within the inner workings of libraries.

Since an uploaded file already has a path it makes sense to implement
the implicit "path" conversion protocol (just like `File` and
`Tempfile`). This change allows uploaded file content to be treated more
closely to regular file content, without requiring any special case
handling or explicit conversion for common file utilities.

* Note uploaded file path delegation in CHANGELOG
This commit is contained in:
Aaron Kromer 2018-07-22 04:00:40 -04:00 committed by Kasper Timm Hansen
parent 76f22e19d6
commit 20543c0496
3 changed files with 21 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@ -1,3 +1,13 @@
* `ActionDispatch::Http::UploadedFile` now delegates `to_path` to its tempfile.
This allows uploaded file objects to be passed directly to `File.read`
without raising a `TypeError`:
uploaded_file = ActionDispatch::Http::UploadedFile.new(tempfile: tmp_file)
File.read(uploaded_file)
*Aaron Kromer*
* Pass along arguments to underlying `get` method in `follow_redirect!`
Now all arguments passed to `follow_redirect!` are passed to the underlying

View File

@ -65,6 +65,11 @@ module ActionDispatch
@tempfile.path
end
# Shortcut for +tempfile.to_path+.
def to_path
@tempfile.to_path
end
# Shortcut for +tempfile.rewind+.
def rewind
@tempfile.rewind

View File

@ -103,6 +103,12 @@ module ActionDispatch
assert_predicate uf, :eof?
end
def test_delegate_to_path_to_tempfile
tf = Class.new { def to_path; "/any/file/path" end; }
uf = Http::UploadedFile.new(tempfile: tf.new)
assert_equal "/any/file/path", uf.to_path
end
def test_respond_to?
tf = Class.new { def read; yield end }
uf = Http::UploadedFile.new(tempfile: tf.new)